Dataset Information

Does the settling column method underestimate phytoplankton sinking speeds?

ABSTRACT: Phytoplankton sinking is a major component of vertical ocean carbon and nutrient fluxes, and sinking is an integral component of phytoplankton biology and ecology. Much of our understanding of phytoplankton sinking derives from the settling column method (SETCOL) in which sinking speeds are calculated from the proportion of cells reaching the bottom of a water-filled column after a set time. Video-based methods are a recent alternative to SETCOL in which sinking speeds are measured by tracking the movement of individual cells in a salinity-stratified water column. In this study, we present the results of a meta-analysis showing that SETCOL produces significantly and consistently lower sinking speeds than the video method. Next, we perform a particle image velocimetry analysis, which shows that the observed discrepancy in sinking speeds between the two methods can probably be explained by weak convection currents in the SETCOLs. Finally, we discuss the implications of these results for the interpretation of past and future phytoplankton sinking speed measurements and models that rely on those measurements.

SUBMITTER: Du Clos KT

PROVIDER: S-EPMC10846949 | biostudies-literature | 2024 Feb

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Does the settling column method underestimate phytoplankton sinking speeds?

Du Clos Kevin T KT Gemmell Brad J BJ

Royal Society open science 20240207 2

Phytoplankton sinking is a major component of vertical ocean carbon and nutrient fluxes, and sinking is an integral component of phytoplankton biology and ecology. Much of our understanding of phytoplankton sinking derives from the settling column method (SETCOL) in which sinking speeds are calculated from the proportion of cells reaching the bottom of a water-filled column after a set time. Video-based methods are a recent alternative to SETCOL in which sinking speeds are measured by tracking t ...[more]

PMID: 38328572

Similar Datasets

Project description:Diatoms are marine primary producers that sink in part due to the density of their silica frustules. Sinking of these phytoplankters is crucial for both the biological pump that sequesters carbon to the deep ocean and for the life strategy of the organism. Sinking rates have been previously measured through settling columns, or with fluorimeters or video microscopy arranged perpendicularly to the direction of sinking. These side-view techniques require large volumes of culture, specialized equipment and are difficult to scale up to multiple simultaneous measures for screening. We established a method for parallel, large scale analysis of multiple phytoplankton sinking rates through top-view monitoring of chlorophyll a fluorescence in microtitre well plates. We verified the method through experimental analysis of known factors that influence sinking rates, including exponential versus stationary growth phase in species of different cell sizes; Thalassiosira pseudonana CCMP1335, chain-forming Skeletonema marinoi RO5A and Coscinodiscus radiatus CCMP312. We fit decay curves to an algebraic transform of the decrease in fluorescence signal as cells sank away from the fluorometer detector, and then used minimal mechanistic assumptions to extract a sinking rate (m d-1) using an RStudio script, SinkWORX. We thereby detected significant differences in sinking rates as larger diatom cells sank faster than smaller cells, and cultures in stationary phase sank faster than those in exponential phase. Our sinking rate estimates accord well with literature values from previously established methods. This well plate-based method can operate as a high throughput integrative phenotypic screen for factors that influence sinking rates including macromolecular allocations, nutrient availability or uptake rates, chain-length or cell size, degree of silification and progression through growth stages. Alternately the approach can be used to phenomically screen libraries of mutants.

Project description:Bacteria and archaea are central to the production, consumption, and remineralization of dissolved and particulate organic matter and contribute critically to carbon delivery, nutrient availability, and energy transformations in the deep ocean. To explore environmentally relevant genomic traits of sinking-particle-associated versus free-living microbes, we compared habitat-specific metagenome-assembled genomes recovered throughout the water column in the North Pacific Subtropical Gyre. The genomic traits of sinking-particle-associated versus free-living prokaryotes were compositionally, functionally, and phylogenetically distinct. Substrate-specific transporters and extracellular peptidases and carbohydrate-active enzymes were more enriched and diverse in particle-associated microbes at all depths than in free-living counterparts. These data indicate specific roles for particle-attached microbes in particle substrate hydrolysis, uptake, and remineralization. Shallow-water particle-associated microbes had elevated genomic GC content and proteome nitrogen content and reduced proteome carbon content in comparison to abyssal particle-associated microbes. An inverse trend was observed for their sympatric free-living counterparts. These different properties of attached microbes are postulated to arise in part due to elevated organic and inorganic nitrogen availability inside sinking particles. Particle-attached microbes also were enriched in genes for environmental sensing via two-component regulatory systems, and cell-cell interactions via extracellular secretion systems, reflecting their surface-adapted lifestyles. Finally, particle-attached bacteria had greater predicted maximal growth efficiencies than free-living bacterioplankton at all depths. All of these particle-associated specific genomic and proteomic features appear to be driven by microhabitat-specific elevated nutrient and energy availability as well as surface-associated competitive and synergistic ecological interactions. Although some of these characteristics have been previously postulated or observed individually, we report them together here in aggregate via direct comparisons of cooccurring free-living and sinking-particle-attached microbial genomes from the open ocean. IMPORTANCE Particle-attached microbes play large roles in the ocean carbon cycle and help to sequester atmospheric CO2 and to deliver nutrients and energy on sinking particles to the deep sea. Here, we report on the genomic traits of particle-attached versus free-living microbes throughout the ocean water column to better differentiate their specific metabolic and ecological roles in the sea. In general, the genomic properties and contents of particle-attached microbes reflected the physical and chemical compositions of their environment as well as their microhabitat-specific adaptive traits. In comparison to cooccurring free-living microbes, particle-attached microbes had larger genomes, greater capacity for extracellular polymer degradation, greater environmental sensing and response capacity, greater potential for motility and attachment, and higher growth efficiencies. Our results present an integrated new perspective on sinking-particle-attached microbial adaptive traits that contribute to their critical ecological and biogeochemical roles and activities in the sea.

Project description:Phytoplankton underpin the marine food web in shelf seas, with some species having properties that are harmful to human health and coastal aquaculture. Pressures such as climate change and anthropogenic nutrient input are hypothesized to influence phytoplankton community composition and distribution. Yet the primary environmental drivers in shelf seas are poorly understood. To begin to address this in North Western European waters, the phytoplankton community composition was assessed in light of measured physical and chemical drivers during the "Ellett Line" cruise of autumn 2001 across the Scottish Continental shelf and into adjacent open Atlantic waters. Spatial variability existed in both phytoplankton and environmental conditions, with clear differences not only between on and off shelf stations but also between different on shelf locations. Temperature/salinity plots demonstrated different water masses existed in the region. In turn, principal component analysis (PCA), of the measured environmental conditions (temperature, salinity, water density and inorganic nutrient concentrations) clearly discriminated between shelf and oceanic stations on the basis of DIN:DSi ratio that was correlated with both salinity and temperature. Discrimination between shelf stations was also related to this ratio, but also the concentration of DIN and DSi. The phytoplankton community was diatom dominated, with multidimensional scaling (MDS) demonstrating spatial variability in its composition. Redundancy analysis (RDA) was used to investigate the link between environment and the phytoplankton community. This demonstrated a significant relationship between community composition and water mass as indexed by salinity (whole community), and both salinity and DIN:DSi (diatoms alone). Diatoms of the Pseudo-nitzschia seriata group occurred at densities potentially harmful to shellfish aquaculture, with the potential for toxicity being elevated by the likelihood of DSi limitation of growth at most stations and depths.

Dataset Information

Does the settling column method underestimate phytoplankton sinking speeds?

Publications

Does the settling column method underestimate phytoplankton sinking speeds?

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets