Unknown

Dataset Information

Personal attributes of authors and reviewers, social bias and the outcomes of peer review: a case study.


ABSTRACT: Peer review is the "gold standard" for evaluating journal and conference papers, research proposals, on-going projects and university departments. However, it is widely believed that current systems are expensive, conservative and prone to various forms of bias. One form of bias identified in the literature is "social bias" linked to the personal attributes of authors and reviewers. To quantify the importance of this form of bias in modern peer review, we analyze three datasets providing information on the attributes of authors and reviewers and review outcomes: one from Frontiers - an open access publishing house with a novel interactive review process, and two from Spanish and international computer science conferences, which use traditional peer review. We use a random intercept model i

SUBMITTER: Walker R 

PROVIDER: S-EPMC4648219 | biostudies-literature | 2015

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature