Dataset Information

Falling from grace: HPRT is not suitable as an endogenous control for cancer-related studies.

ABSTRACT: HPRT is a housekeeping enzyme involved in recycling guanine and inosine in the purine salvage pathway. As a housekeeping gene, HPRT has been widely used as an endogenous control for molecular studies evaluating changes in gene expression. Yet, recent evidence has shown that HPRT exhibits high variability within malignant samples. We designed this study to determine whether this observed upregulation is consistently found, therefore rendering hprt an unsuitable normalization control in cancer. Utilizing protein and RNA-seq expression, we found that malignant and normal patient samples vary significantly both within the same tissue type and across organ sites. Upon staining for HPRT via immunohistochemistry, we found that expression is highly variable in malignant samples (Lung; 89.2-111.8, Breast; 66.7-98.3, Colon; 85.3-129.7, Prostate; 90.8-155.4, Pancreas; 74.1-132.1). Similarly, we observed high variability across cell lines via western blotting (p < 0.0001) which was further confirmed using RNA sequencing. Comparing normal and malignant patient samples, we observed consistent upregulation of HPRT expression within malignant samples relative to normal samples (p = 0.0001). These data indicate that HPRT is unsuitable as an endogenous control for cancer-related studies because its expression is highly variable and exceeds that of an appropriate control; therefore, we recommend its discontinued use as a normalization gene.

SUBMITTER: Townsend MH

PROVIDER: S-EPMC6512905 | biostudies-literature | 2019

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Falling from grace: HPRT is not suitable as an endogenous control for cancer-related studies.

Townsend Michelle H MH Felsted Abigail M AM Ence Zac E ZE Piccolo Stephen R SR Robison Richard A RA O'Neill Kim L KL

Molecular & cellular oncology 20190226 2

HPRT is a housekeeping enzyme involved in recycling guanine and inosine in the purine salvage pathway. As a housekeeping gene, HPRT has been widely used as an endogenous control for molecular studies evaluating changes in gene expression. Yet, recent evidence has shown that HPRT exhibits high variability within malignant samples. We designed this study to determine whether this observed upregulation is consistently found, therefore rendering <i>hprt</i> an unsuitable normalization control in can ...[more]

PMID: 31131300

Similar Datasets

Project description:MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are promising tools as biomarkers and therapeutic agents in various chronic diseases such as osteoporosis, cancers, type I and II diabetes, and cardiovascular diseases. Considering the rising interest in the regulatory role of miRNAs in bone metabolism, aging, and cellular senescence, accurate normalization of qPCR-based miRNA expression data using an optimal endogenous control becomes crucial. We used a systematic approach to select candidate endogenous control miRNAs that exhibit high stability with aging from our miRNA sequence data and literature search. Validation of miRNA expression was performed using qPCR and their comprehensive stability was assessed using the RefFinder tool which is based on four statistical algorithms: GeNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and comparative delta CT. The selected endogenous control was then validated for its stability in mice and human bone tissues, and in bone marrow stromal cells (BMSCs) following induction of senescence and senolytic treatment. Finally, the utility of selected endogenous control versus U6 was tested by using each as a normalizer to measure the expression of miR-34a, a miRNA known to increase with age and senescence. Our results show that Let-7f did not change across the groups with aging, senescence or senolytic treatment, and was the most stable miRNA, whereas U6 was the least stable. Moreover, using Let-7f as a normalizer resulted in significantly increased expression of miR-34a with aging and senescence and decreased expression following senolytic treatment. However, the expression pattern for miR-34a reversed for each of these conditions when U6 was used as a normalizer. We show that optimal endogenous control miRNAs, such as Let-7f, are essential for accurate normalization of miRNA expression data to increase the reliability of results and prevent misinterpretation. Moreover, we present a systematic strategy that is transferrable and can easily be used to identify endogenous control miRNAs in other biological systems and conditions.

Dataset Information

Falling from grace: HPRT is not suitable as an endogenous control for cancer-related studies.

Publications

Falling from grace: HPRT is not suitable as an endogenous control for cancer-related studies.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets