Dataset Information

Robust and interpretable PAM50 reclassification exhibits survival advantage for myoepithelial and immune phenotypes.

ABSTRACT: We introduce a classification of breast tumors into seven classes which are more clearly defined by interpretable mRNA signatures along the PAM50 gene set than the five traditional PAM50 intrinsic subtypes. Each intrinsic subtype is partially concordant with one of our classes, and the two additional classes correspond to division of the classes concordant with the Luminal B and the Normal intrinsic subtypes along expression of the Her2 gene group. Our Normal class shows similarity with the myoepithelial mammary cell phenotype, including TP63 expression (specificity: 80.8% and sensitivity: 82.8%), and exhibits the best overall survival (89.6% at 5 years). Though Luminal A tumors are traditionally considered the least aggressive, our analysis shows that only the Luminal A tumors which are now classified as myoepithelial have this phenotype, while tumors in our luminal class (concordant with Luminal A) may be more aggressive than previously thought. We also find that patients with basal tumors surviving to 48 months exhibit favorable continued survival rates when certain markers for B lymphocytes are present and poor survival rates when they are absent, which is consistent with recent findings.

SUBMITTER: Mathews JC

PROVIDER: S-EPMC6733897 | biostudies-literature | 2019

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Robust and interpretable PAM50 reclassification exhibits survival advantage for myoepithelial and immune phenotypes.

Mathews James C JC Nadeem Saad S Levine Arnold J AJ Pouryahya Maryam M Deasy Joseph O JO Tannenbaum Allen A

NPJ breast cancer 20190909

We introduce a classification of breast tumors into seven classes which are more clearly defined by interpretable mRNA signatures along the PAM50 gene set than the five traditional PAM50 intrinsic subtypes. Each intrinsic subtype is partially concordant with one of our classes, and the two additional classes correspond to division of the classes concordant with the Luminal B and the Normal intrinsic subtypes along expression of the Her2 gene group. Our Normal class shows similarity with the myoe ...[more]

PMID: 31531391

Similar Datasets

Project description:BackgroundProstate cancer (PCa) is among the most common cancers in men and its diagnosis requires the histopathological evaluation of biopsies by human experts. While several recent artificial intelligence-based (AI) approaches have reached human expert-level PCa grading, they often display significantly reduced performance on external datasets. This reduced performance can be caused by variations in sample preparation, for instance the staining protocol, section thickness, or scanner used. Another limiting factor of contemporary AI-based PCa grading is the prediction of ISUP grades, which leads to the perpetuation of human annotation errors.MethodsWe developed the prostate cancer aggressiveness index (PCAI), an AI-based PCa detection and grading framework that is trained on objective patient outcome, rather than subjective ISUP grades. We designed PCAI as a clinical application, containing algorithmic modules that offer robustness to data variation, medical interpretability, and a measure of prediction confidence. To train and evaluate PCAI, we generated a multicentric, retrospective, observational trial consisting of six cohorts with 25,591 patients, 83,864 images, and 5 years of median follow-up from 5 different centers and 3 countries. This includes a high-variance dataset of 8,157 patients and 28,236 images with variations in sample thickness, staining protocol, and scanner, allowing for the systematic evaluation and optimization of model robustness to data variation. The performance of PCAI was assessed on three external test cohorts from two countries, comprising 2,255 patients and 9,437 images.FindingsUsing our high-variance datasets, we show how differences in sample processing, particularly slide thickness and staining time, significantly reduce the performance of AI-based PCa grading by up to 6.2 percentage points in the concordance index (C-index). We show how a select set of algorithmic improvements, including domain adversarial training, conferred robustness to data variation, interpretability, and a measure of credibility to PCAI. These changes lead to significant prediction improvement across two biopsy cohorts and one TMA cohort, systematically exceeding expert ISUP grading in C-index and AUROC by up to 22 percentage points.InterpretationData variation poses serious risks for AI-based histopathological PCa grading, even when models are trained on large datasets. Algorithmic improvements for model robustness, interpretability, credibility, and training on high-variance data as well as outcome-based severity prediction gives rise to robust models with above ISUP-level PCa grading performance.

Dataset Information

Robust and interpretable PAM50 reclassification exhibits survival advantage for myoepithelial and immune phenotypes.

Publications

Robust and interpretable PAM50 reclassification exhibits survival advantage for myoepithelial and immune phenotypes.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets