Dataset Information

Reflection on modern methods: shared-parameter models for longitudinal studies with missing data.

ABSTRACT: A primary goal of longitudinal studies is to examine trends over time. Reported results from these studies often depend on strong, unverifiable assumptions about the missing data. Whereas the risk of substantial bias from missing data is widely known, analyses exploring missing-data influences are commonly done either ad hoc or not at all. This article outlines one of the three primary recognized approaches for examining missing-data effects that could be more widely used, i.e. the shared-parameter model (SPM), and explains its purpose, use, limitations and extensions. We additionally provide synthetic data and reproducible research code for running SPMs in SAS, Stata and R programming languages to facilitate their use in practice and for teaching purposes in epidemiology, biostatistics, data science and related fields. Our goals are to increase understanding and use of these methods by providing introductions to the concepts and access to helpful tools.

SUBMITTER: Griswold ME

PROVIDER: S-EPMC8407871 | biostudies-literature | 2021 Aug

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Reflection on modern methods: shared-parameter models for longitudinal studies with missing data.

Griswold Michael E ME Talluri Rajesh R Zhu Xiaoqian X Su Dan D Tingle Jonathan J Gottesman Rebecca F RF Deal Jennifer J Rawlings Andreea M AM Mosley Thomas H TH Windham B Gwen BG Bandeen-Roche Karen K

International journal of epidemiology 20210801 4

A primary goal of longitudinal studies is to examine trends over time. Reported results from these studies often depend on strong, unverifiable assumptions about the missing data. Whereas the risk of substantial bias from missing data is widely known, analyses exploring missing-data influences are commonly done either ad hoc or not at all. This article outlines one of the three primary recognized approaches for examining missing-data effects that could be more widely used, i.e. the shared-parame ...[more]

PMID: 34113988

Similar Datasets

Project description:Joint modeling of longitudinal and time-to-event data, particularly through shared parameter models (SPMs), is a common approach for handling longitudinal marker data with an informative terminal event. A critical but often neglected assumption in this context is that the visiting/observation process is noninformative, depending solely on past marker values and visit times. When this assumption fails, the visiting process becomes informative, resulting potentially to biased SPM estimates. Existing methods generally rely on a conditional independence assumption, positing that the marker model, visiting process, and time-to-event model are independent given shared or correlated random effects. Moreover, they are typically built on an intensity-based visiting process using calendar time. This study introduces a unified approach for jointly modeling a normally distributed marker, the visiting process, and time-to-event data in the form of competing risks. Our model conditions on the history of observed marker values, prior visit times, the marker's random effects, and possibly a frailty term independent of the random effects. While our approach aligns with the shared-parameter framework, it does not presume conditional independence between the processes. Additionally, the visiting process can be defined on either a gap time scale, via proportional hazard models, or a calendar time scale, via proportional intensity models. Through extensive simulation studies, we assess the performance of our proposed methodology. We demonstrate that disregarding an informative visiting process can yield significantly biased marker estimates. However, misspecification of the visiting process can also lead to biased estimates. The gap time formulation exhibits greater robustness compared to the intensity-based model when the visiting process is misspecified. In general, enriching the visiting process with prior visit history enhances performance. We further apply our methodology to real longitudinal data from HIV, where visit frequency varies substantially among individuals.

Dataset Information

Reflection on modern methods: shared-parameter models for longitudinal studies with missing data.

Publications

Reflection on modern methods: shared-parameter models for longitudinal studies with missing data.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets