Peer reviewers equally critique theory, method, and writing, with limited effect on the final content of accepted manuscripts.
Ontology highlight
ABSTRACT: The primary aims of peer review are to detect flaws and deficiencies in the design and interpretation of studies, and ensure the clarity and quality of their presentation. However, it has been questioned whether peer review fulfils this function. Studies have highlighted a stronger focus of reviewers on critiquing methodological aspects of studies and the quality of writing in biomedical sciences, with less focus on theoretical grounding. In contrast, reviewers in the social sciences appear more concerned with theoretical underpinnings. These studies also found the effect of peer review on manuscripts' content to be variable, but generally modest and positive. I qualitatively analysed 1430 peer reviewers' comments for a sample of 40 social science preprint-publication pairs to identify the
SUBMITTER: Stephen D
PROVIDER: S-EPMC8993676 | biostudies-literature | 2022
REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature
ACCESS DATA