How experts' own inconsistency relates to their confidence and between-expert disagreement.
Ontology highlight
ABSTRACT: People routinely rely on experts' advice to guide their decisions. However, experts are known to make inconsistent judgments when judging the same case twice. Previous research on expert inconsistency has largely focused on individual or situational factors; here we focus directly on the cases themselves. First, using a theoretical model, we study how within-expert inconsistency and confidence are related to how strongly experts agree on a case. Second, we empirically test the model's predictions in two real-world datasets with a diagnostic ground truth from follow-up research: diagnosticians rating the same mammograms or images of the lower spine twice. Our modeling and empirical analyses converge on the same novel results: The more experts disagree in their initial decisions about a case
SUBMITTER: Litvinova A
PROVIDER: S-EPMC9166728 | biostudies-literature | 2022 Jun
REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature
ACCESS DATA