Dataset Information

Implementation of an Alternative Method for Assessing Competing Risks: Restricted Mean Time Lost.

ABSTRACT: In clinical and epidemiologic studies, hazard ratios are often applied to compare treatment effects between 2 groups for survival data. For competing-risks data, the corresponding quantities of interest are cause-specific hazard ratios and subdistribution hazard ratios. However, they both have some limitations related to model assumptions and clinical interpretation. Therefore, we recommend restricted mean time lost (RMTL) as an alternative measure that is easy to interpret in a competing-risks framework. Based on the difference in RMTL (RMTLd), we propose a new estimator, hypothetical test, and sample-size formula. Simulation results show that estimation of the RMTLd is accurate and that the RMTLd test has robust statistical performance (both type I error and statistical power). The results of 3 example analyses also verify the performance of the RMTLd test. From the perspectives of clinical interpretation, application conditions, and statistical performance, we recommend that the RMTLd be reported along with the hazard ratio in analyses of competing-risks data and that the RMTLd even be regarded as the primary outcome when the proportional hazards assumption fails.

SUBMITTER: Wu H

PROVIDER: S-EPMC9180943 | biostudies-literature | 2022 Jan

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Implementation of an Alternative Method for Assessing Competing Risks: Restricted Mean Time Lost.

Wu Hongji H Yuan Hao H Yang Zijing Z Hou Yawen Y Chen Zheng Z

American journal of epidemiology 20220101 1

In clinical and epidemiologic studies, hazard ratios are often applied to compare treatment effects between 2 groups for survival data. For competing-risks data, the corresponding quantities of interest are cause-specific hazard ratios and subdistribution hazard ratios. However, they both have some limitations related to model assumptions and clinical interpretation. Therefore, we recommend restricted mean time lost (RMTL) as an alternative measure that is easy to interpret in a competing-risks ...[more]

PMID: 34550319

Similar Datasets

Project description:BackgroundAccording to long-term follow-up data of malignant tumor patients, assessing treatment effects requires careful consideration of competing risks. The commonly used cause-specific hazard ratio (CHR) and sub-distribution hazard ratio (SHR) are relative indicators and may present challenges in terms of proportional hazards assumption and clinical interpretation. Recently, the restricted mean time lost (RMTL) has been recommended as a supplementary measure for better clinical interpretation. Moreover, for observational study data in epidemiological and clinical settings, due to the influence of confounding factors, covariate adjustment is crucial for determining the causal effect of treatment.MethodsWe construct an RMTL estimator after adjusting for covariates based on the inverse probability weighting method, and derive the variance to construct interval estimates based on the large sample properties. We use simulation studies to study the statistical performance of this estimator in various scenarios. In addition, we further consider the changes in treatment effects over time, constructing a dynamic RMTL difference curve and corresponding confidence bands for the curve.ResultsThe simulation results demonstrate that the adjusted RMTL estimator exhibits smaller biases compared with unadjusted RMTL and provides robust interval estimates in all scenarios. This method was applied to a real-world cervical cancer patient data, revealing improvements in the prognosis of patients with small cell carcinoma of the cervix. The results showed that the protective effect of surgery was significant only in the first 20 months, but the long-term effect was not obvious. Radiotherapy significantly improved patient outcomes during the follow-up period from 17 to 57 months, while radiotherapy combined with chemotherapy significantly improved patient outcomes throughout the entire period.ConclusionsWe propose the approach that is easy to interpret and implement for assessing treatment effects in observational competing risk data.

Dataset Information

Implementation of an Alternative Method for Assessing Competing Risks: Restricted Mean Time Lost.

Publications

Implementation of an Alternative Method for Assessing Competing Risks: Restricted Mean Time Lost.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets