Dataset Information


Expert prior elicitation and Bayesian analysis of the Mycotic Ulcer Treatment Trial I.

ABSTRACT: To perform a Bayesian analysis of the Mycotic Ulcer Treatment Trial I (MUTT I) using expert opinion as a prior belief.MUTT I was a randomized clinical trial comparing topical natamycin or voriconazole for treating filamentous fungal keratitis. A questionnaire elicited expert opinion on the best treatment of fungal keratitis before MUTT I results were available. A Bayesian analysis was performed using the questionnaire data as a prior belief and the MUTT I primary outcome (3-month visual acuity) by frequentist analysis as a likelihood.Corneal experts had a 41.1% prior belief that natamycin improved 3-month visual acuity compared with voriconazole. The Bayesian analysis found a 98.4% belief for natamycin treatment compared with voriconazole treatment for filamentous cases as a group (mean improvement 1.1 Snellen lines, 95% credible interval 0.1-2.1). The Bayesian analysis estimated a smaller treatment effect than the MUTT I frequentist analysis result of 1.8-line improvement with natamycin versus voriconazole (95% confidence interval 0.5-3.0, P = 0.006). For Fusarium cases, the posterior demonstrated a 99.7% belief for natamycin treatment, whereas non-Fusarium cases had a 57.3% belief.The Bayesian analysis suggests that natamycin is superior to voriconazole when filamentous cases are analyzed as a group. Subgroup analysis of Fusarium cases found improvement with natamycin compared with voriconazole, whereas there was almost no difference between treatments for non-Fusarium cases. These results were consistent with, though smaller in effect size than, the MUTT I primary outcome by frequentist analysis. The accordance between analyses further validates the trial results. (ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00996736.).

PROVIDER: S-EPMC3684218 | BioStudies |

REPOSITORIES: biostudies

Similar Datasets

| S-EPMC3769211 | BioStudies
| S-EPMC5980795 | BioStudies
| S-EPMC5847083 | BioStudies
| S-EPMC3896887 | BioStudies
| S-EPMC5710829 | BioStudies
| S-EPMC4962866 | BioStudies
| S-EPMC8307352 | BioStudies
| S-EPMC4962688 | BioStudies
| S-EPMC6044431 | BioStudies
| S-EPMC6646068 | BioStudies