Dataset Information

Comparison of Full-Scan, Data-Dependent, and Data-Independent Acquisition Modes in Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry Based Untargeted Metabolomics

ABSTRACT: Full-scan, data-dependent acquisition (DDA), and data-independent acquisition (DIA) are the three common data acquisition modes in high resolution mass spectrometry-based untargeted metabolomics. It is an important yet underrated research topic on which acquisition mode is more suitable for a given untargeted metabolomics application. In this work, we compared the three data acquisition techniques using a standard mixture of 134 endogenous metabolites and a human urine sample. Both hydrophilic interaction and reversed-phase liquid chromatographic separation along with positive and negative ionization modes were tested. Both the standard mixture and urine samples generated consistent results. Full-scan mode is able to capture the largest number of metabolic features, followed by DIA and DDA (53.7% and 64.8% respective features fewer on average in urine than full-scan). Comparing the MS2 spectra in DIA and DDA, spectra quality is higher in DDA with average dot product score 83.1% higher than DIA in Urine(H), and the number of MS2 spectra (spectra quantity) is larger in DIA (on average 97.8% more than DDA in urine). Moreover, a comparison of relative standard deviation distribution between modes shows consistency in the quantitative precision, with the exception of DDA showing a minor disadvantage (on average 19.8% and 26.8% fewer features in urine with RSD < 5% than full-scan and DIA). In terms of data preprocessing convenience, full-scan and DDA data can be processed by well-established software. In contrast, several bioinformatic issues remain to be addressed in processing DIA data and the development of more effective computational programs is highly demanded.

INSTRUMENT(S): Liquid Chromatography MS - Reverse Phase (POS)” Liquid Chromatography MS - HILIC (NEG)”, Liquid Chromatography MS - HILIC (NEG), Liquid Chromatography MS - Reverse Phase (POS), Liquid Chromatography MS - Positive (LC-MS (Positive))

SUBMITTER: Jian Guo

PROVIDER: MTBLS1572 | MetaboLights | 2020-05-21

REPOSITORIES: MetaboLights

ACCESS DATA

Publications

Comparison of Full-Scan, Data-Dependent, and Data-Independent Acquisition Modes in Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry Based Untargeted Metabolomics.

Guo Jian J Huan Tao T

Analytical chemistry 20200527 12

Full-scan, data-dependent acquisition (DDA), and data-independent acquisition (DIA) are the three common data acquisition modes in high resolution mass spectrometry-based untargeted metabolomics. It is an important yet underrated research topic on which acquisition mode is more suitable for a given untargeted metabolomics application. In this work, we compared the three data acquisition techniques using a standard mixture of 134 endogenous metabolites and a human urine sample. Both hydrophilic i ...[more]

PMID: 32401506

Similar Datasets

Project description:Data independent acquisition-mass spectrometry (DIA-MS) coupled with liquid chromatography is a promising approach for rapid, automatic sampling of MS/MS data in untargeted metabolomics. However, wide isolation windows in DIA-MS generate MS/MS spectra containing a mixed population of fragment ions together with their precursor ions. This precursor-fragment ion map in a comprehensive MS/MS spectral library is crucial for relative quantification of fragment ions uniquely representative of each precursor ion. However, existing reference libraries are not sufficient for this purpose since the fragmentation patterns of small molecules can vary in different instrument setups. Here we developed a bioinformatics workflow called MetaboDIA to build customized MS/MS spectral libraries using a user's own data dependent acquisition (DDA) data and to perform MS/MS-based quantification with DIA data, thus complementing conventional MS1-based quantification. MetaboDIA also allows users to build a spectral library directly from DIA data in studies of a large sample size. Using a marine algae data set, we show that quantification of fragment ions extracted with a customized MS/MS library can provide as reliable quantitative data as the direct quantification of precursor ions based on MS1 data. To test its applicability in complex samples, we applied MetaboDIA to a clinical serum metabolomics data set, where we built a DDA-based spectral library containing consensus spectra for 1829 compounds. We performed fragment ion quantification using DIA data using this library, yielding sensitive differential expression analysis. </br></br> Serum metabolome of 40 age-related macular degeneration patients and 20 control samples was analyzed using untargeted mass spectrometry. We used data dependent acquisition data to build a MS/MS spectral assay library for more than 1,000 compounds and performed targeted extraction of MS2 ion chromatograms from data independent acquisition analysis.

Project description:The sensitivity of single-cell proteomics (SCP) has increased dramatically in recent years due to advances in experimental design, sample preparation, separations and mass spectrometry instrumentation. However, further increasing the sensitivity of SCP methods and instrumentation will enable the study of proteins within single cells that are expressed at copy numbers too small to be measured by current methods. Here we further increase SCP sensitivity by combining efficient nanoPOTS sample preparation and ultra-low-flow liquid chromatography with a newly developed data acquisition and analysis scheme termed wide window acquisition (WWA) to extend the achievable proteome coverage for single cells to >3,000 for single-cell data analyses. WWA is based on data-dependent acquisition (DDA) but employs larger precursor isolation windows to intentionally co-isolate and co-fragment additional precursors along with the selected precursor. The resulting chimeric MS2 spectra are then resolved using the CHIMERYS search engine within Proteome Discoverer 3.0. Compared to standard DDA workflows, WWA employing isolation windows of 8-12 Th increases peptide and proteome coverage by ~28% and ~39%, respectively. For a 40 min LC gradient operated at ~15 nL/min, we identified an average of 2,150 proteins per single-cell-sized aliquots of protein digest directly from MS2 spectra, which increased to an average 3,524 proteins including proteins identified with MS1-level feature matching. Reducing the active gradient to 20 min resulted in only a 10% decrease in proteome coverage. We also compared performance of WWA with DIA underperformed relative to WWA in terms of proteome coverage, especially with faster separations. Average proteome coverage for single HeLa and K562 cells was respectively 1,758 and 1,642 based on MS2 identifications with 1% false discovery rate and 3042 and 2891 with MS1 feature matching. As such, WWA combined with efficient sample preparation and rapid separations extends the depths of the proteome that can be studied at the single-cell level.

Dataset Information

Comparison of Full-Scan, Data-Dependent, and Data-Independent Acquisition Modes in Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry Based Untargeted Metabolomics

Publications

Comparison of Full-Scan, Data-Dependent, and Data-Independent Acquisition Modes in Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry Based Untargeted Metabolomics.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure