Dataset Information

When Unsuspected Crystallinity Ruins Biological Testing in Early Discovery: A Case Study.

ABSTRACT: The impact of the crystalline or amorphous structure of a solid on the solubility and pharmacokinetic properties of a drug candidate is always considered by the pharmaceutical industry during the development of a new drug; however, it is not so frequently considered during the early drug discovery process by organic and medicinal chemists, particularly those working in academia. We want to share, as an example, the false negative obtained in the biological testing of a solid sample of a tyrosine kinase inhibitor due to its unexpected crystallinity and lower solubility with respect to a solid amorphous batch of the same compound and the experimentation carried out to establish the origin of such a discrepancy.

SUBMITTER: de Rocafiguera C

PROVIDER: S-EPMC10976151 | biostudies-literature | 2024 Feb

REPOSITORIES: biostudies-literature

ACCESS DATA

Publications

When Unsuspected Crystallinity Ruins Biological Testing in Early Discovery: A Case Study.

de Rocafiguera Claudi C Belsa Blanca B Font-Bardia Mercè M Puigjaner Cristina C Serra Eduard E Cuartero-Albesa Ana M AM Puig de la Bellacasa Raimon R Borrell José I JI

Pharmaceuticals (Basel, Switzerland) 20240222 3

The impact of the crystalline or amorphous structure of a solid on the solubility and pharmacokinetic properties of a drug candidate is always considered by the pharmaceutical industry during the development of a new drug; however, it is not so frequently considered during the early drug discovery process by organic and medicinal chemists, particularly those working in academia. We want to share, as an example, the false negative obtained in the biological testing of a solid sample of a tyrosine ...[more]

PMID: 38543069

Similar Datasets

Project description:BackgroundIn Literature-based Discovery (LBD), Swanson's original ABC model brought together isolated public knowledge statements and assembled them to infer putative hypotheses via logical connections. Modern LBD studies that scale up this approach through automation typically rely on a simple entity-based knowledge graph with co-occurrences and/or semantic triples as basic building blocks. However, our analysis of a knowledge graph constructed for a recent LBD system reveals limitations arising from such pairwise representations, which further negatively impact knowledge inference. Using LBD as the context and motivation in this work, we explore limitations of using pairwise relationships only as knowledge representation in knowledge graphs, and we identify impacts of these limitations on knowledge inference. We argue that enhanced knowledge representation is beneficial for biological knowledge representation in general, as well as for both the quality and the specificity of hypotheses proposed with LBD.ResultsBased on a systematic analysis of one co-occurrence-based LBD system focusing on Alzheimer's Disease, we identify 7 types of limitations arising from the exclusive use of pairwise relationships in a standard knowledge graph-including the need to capture more than two entities interacting together in a single event-and 3 types of negative impacts on knowledge inferred with the graph-Experimentally infeasible hypotheses, Literature-inconsistent hypotheses, and Oversimplified hypotheses explanations. We also present an indicative distribution of different types of relationships. Pairwise relationships are an essential component in representation frameworks for knowledge discovery. However, only 20% of discoveries are perfectly represented with pairwise relationships alone. 73% require a combination of pairwise relationships and nested relationships. The remaining 7% are represented with pairwise relationships, nested relationships, and hypergraphs.ConclusionWe argue that the standard entity pair-based knowledge graph, while essential for representing basic binary relations, results in important limitations for comprehensive biological knowledge representation and impacts downstream tasks such as proposing meaningful discoveries in LBD. These limitations can be mitigated by integrating more semantically complex knowledge representation strategies, including capturing collective interactions and allowing for nested entities. The use of more sophisticated knowledge representation will benefit biological fields with more expressive knowledge graphs. Downstream tasks, such as LBD, can benefit from richer representations as well, allowing for generation of implicit knowledge discoveries and explanations for disease diagnosis, treatment, and mechanism that are more biologically meaningful.

Project description:Biological activity at deep-sea hydrothermal chimneys is driven by chemotrophic microorganisms that metabolize chemicals from the venting high-temperature fluids. Understanding taphonomy and microbial microtextures in such environments is a necessity for micropaleontological and palaeoecological research. This study examines fossilized microorganisms and related microtextures in a recent black smoker from the Roman Ruins hydrothermal vent site, Eastern Manus Basin offshore of Papua New Guinea. Whereas the center of the examined sulfide chimney is dominated by high-temperature mineralogy (chalcopyrite and dendritic sphalerite), filamentous and coccoidal biomorphs occur in an outer, warm zone of mixing between hydrothermal fluids and seawater, which is indicated by their occurrence within colloform and botryoidal pyrite of barite-pyrite coprecipitates. Both morphotypes can be interpreted as thermophilic microorganisms based on their occurrence in a high-temperature habitat. Their separate (non-commensal) occurrence hints at sensitivities to microenvironmental conditions, which is expectable for strong temperature, pH, and redox gradients at the walls of deep-sea hydrothermal chimneys. Whereas both morphotypes experienced mild thermal overprint, taphonomic differences exist: (i) spaces left by cells in filamentous fossils are predominately filled by silica, whereas inter/extracellular features (crosswalls/septae and outer sheaths) are pyritized; (ii) coccoidal fossils show both silica- and pyrite-infilled interiors, and generally better preservation of cell walls. These different manifestations presumably relate to an interplay between microenvironmental and biological factors, potentially contrasting metabolisms, and differences in cell wall chemistries of distinct bacteria and/or archaea. A further hypothesis is that the coccoidal features represent biofilm-forming organisms, whose organic matter derivates contributed to the formation of intimately associated wavy and wrinkly carbonaceous laminations that are at least locally distinguishable from the texture of the surrounding pyrite. Hence, the presented data provide evidence that microtextures of microbiota from hydrothermal systems can have a similar significance for palaeobiological research as those from sedimentary environments.

Dataset Information

When Unsuspected Crystallinity Ruins Biological Testing in Early Discovery: A Case Study.

Publications

When Unsuspected Crystallinity Ruins Biological Testing in Early Discovery: A Case Study.

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets