Dataset Information

Comparative Analysis of Glycoproteomic Software Using a Tailored Glycan Database

ABSTRACT: Glycoproteomics is a rapidly developing field, and data analysis has been stimulated by several technological innovations. As a result, there are many software tools from which to choose; and each comes with unique features that can be difficult to compare. This work presents a head-to-head comparison of five modern analytical software: Byonic, Protein Prospector, MSFraggerGlyco, pGlyco3, and GlycoDecipher. To enable a meaningful comparison, parameter variables were minimized. One potential confounding variable is the glycan database that informs glycoproteomic searches. We performed glycomic profiling of the samples and used the output to construct matched glycan databases for each software. Up to 17,000 glycopeptide spectra were identified across three replicates of wild-type SH-SY5Y cells. There was overlap among all software for glycoproteins identified, locations of glycosites, and glycans; but there was no clear winner. Incorporation of several comparative criteria was critically important for learning the most information in this study and should be used more broadly when assessing software. A single criterion, such as number of glycopeptide spectra found, is not sufficient. We present evidence that suggests Byonic reports many spurious results at the glycoprotein and glycosite level. Overall, our results indicate that glycoproteomic searches should involve more than one software, excluding the current version of Byonic, to generate confidence by consensus. It may be useful to consider software with peptide-first approaches and with glycan-first approaches.

INSTRUMENT(S): Orbitrap Fusion Lumos

ORGANISM(S): Homo Sapiens (ncbitaxon:9606)

SUBMITTER: Robert Chalkley

PROVIDER: MSV000096821 | MassIVE | Fri Jan 10 06:35:00 GMT 2025

SECONDARY ACCESSION(S): PXD059632

REPOSITORIES: MassIVE

ACCESS DATA

Dataset's files

Source:

			Action	DRS
		Other

Items per page:

1 - 1 of 1

Similar Datasets

Project description:High-throughput intact glycopeptide analysis is crucial for elucidating the physiological and pathological status of the glycans attached to each glycoprotein. Mass spectrometry-based glycoproteomic methods are challenging because of the diversity and heterogeneity of glycan structures. Therefore, we developed an MS1-based site-specific glycoform analysis method named "Glycan heterogeneity-based Relational IDentification of Glycopeptide signals on Elution profile (Glyco-RIDGE)" for a more comprehensive analysis. This method detects glycopeptide signals as a cluster based on the mass and chromatographic properties of glycopeptides and then searches for each combination of core peptides and glycan compositions by matching their mass and retention time differences. Here, we developed a novel browser-based software named GRable for semi-automated Glyco-RIDGE analysis with significant improvements in glycopeptide detection algorithms, including "parallel clustering." This unique function improved the comprehensiveness of glycopeptide detection and allowed the analysis to focus on specific glycan structures, such as pauci-mannose. The other notable improvement is evaluating the "confidence level" of the GRable results, especially using MS2 information. This function facilitated reduced misassignment of the core peptide and glycan composition and improved the interpretation of the results. Additional improved points of the algorithms are "correction function" for accurate monoisotopic peak picking; one-to-one correspondence of clusters and core peptides even for multiply sialylated glycopeptides; and "inter-cluster analysis" function for understanding the reason for detected but unmatched clusters. The significance of these improvements was demonstrated using purified and crude glycoprotein samples, showing that GRable allowed site-specific glycoform analysis of intact sialylated glycoproteins on a large-scale and in-depth. Therefore, this software will help us analyze the status and changes in glycans to obtain biological and clinical insights into protein glycosylation by complementing the comprehensiveness of MS2-based glycoproteomics. GRable can be freely run online using a web browser via the GlyCosmos Portal (https://glycosmos.org/grable).

Project description:Recent advances in software-driven glycopeptide identification in LC-MS/MS-based N-glycoproteomics have facilitated biochemical studies reporting thousands of intact N-glycopeptides, i.e. N-glycan-conjugated peptides, but the automated identification process remains to be scrutinized. Herein, we explore the efficiency of site-specific glycoprofiling using the PTM-centric search-engine Byonic relative to manual expert annotation. To allow an appropriately deep comparison, the study utilised typical glycoproteomics acquisition and data analysis strategies, but of a single glycoprotein, the uncharacterised N-glycosylated (Asn160, Asn268 and Asn302) human basigin. Detailed site-specific reference glycoprofiles of purified basigin were manually established using ion trap CID-MS/MS and high-resolution Q-Exactive Orbitrap HCD-MS/MS acquisition of tryptic N-glycopeptides and released N-glycans. The basigin N-glycosylation sites, which showed extensive micro- and macro-heterogeneity, were then glycoprofiled using Byonic with or without a background of complex peptides using Q-Exactive Orbitrap HCD-MS/MS data. The glycoprofiling efficiencies were assessed against the site-specific reference glycoprofiles and target and decoy proteome databases. The search criteria and confidence thresholds (Byonic scores) recommended by the vendor provided very high glycoprofiling accuracy and coverage (both >80%) and low peptide FDRs (<1%). The data complexity, search parameters including search space (proteome/glycome size), mass tolerance and peptide modifications, and confidence thresholds affected the glycoprofiling efficiency and analysis time. Automated identification of peptide modifications (methionine oxidation/carbamidomethylation) that coincide with monosaccharide mass differences (Fuc/Hex/HexNAc) and accurately distinguishing isobaric (Hex1NeuAc1-R/Fuc1NeuGc1-R) or near-isobaric (NeuAc1-R/Fuc2-R) monosaccharide sub-compositions remain challenging, arguing particular attention to such “difficult-to-identify” N-glycopeptides. The presented analysis provides valuable insights into automated glycopeptide identification; knowledge that facilitates further developments in FDR-based glycoproteomics.

Project description:Human noroviruses, globally the main cause of viral gastroenteritis, show strain specific affinity for histo-blood group antigens (HBGA) and can successfully be propagated ex vivo in human intestinal enteroids (HIEs). HIEs established from jejunal stem cells of individuals with different ABO, Lewis and secretor geno- and phenotypes, show varying susceptibility to such infections. Using bottom-up glycoproteomic approaches we have defined and compared the N-linked glycans of glycoproteins of seven jejunal HIEs. Membrane proteins were extracted, trypsin digested, and glycopeptides enriched by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography and analyzed by nanoLC-MS/MS. The Byonic software was used for glycopeptide identification followed by hands-on verifications and interpretations. Glycan structures and attachment sites were identified from MS 2 spectra obtained by higher-energy collision dissociation through analysis of diagnostic saccharide oxonium ions (B-ions), stepwise glycosidic fragmentation of the glycans (Y-ions), and peptide sequence ions (b- and y-ions). Altogether 694 unique glycopeptides from 93 glycoproteins were identified. The N-glycans encompassed pauci- and oligomannose, hybrid- and complex-type structures. Notably, polyfucosylated HBGA-containing glycopeptides of the four glycoproteins tetraspanin-8, carcinoembryonic antigen-related cell adhesion molecule 5, sucrose-isomaltase and aminopeptidase N were especially prominent and were characterized in detail and related to donor ABO, Lewis and secretor types of each HIE. Virtually no sialylated N-glycans were identified for these glycoproteins suggesting that terminal sialylation was infrequent compared to fucosylation and HBGA biosynthesis. This approach gives unique site-specific information on the structural complexity of N-linked glycans of glycoproteins of human HIEs and provides a platform for future studies on the role of host glycoproteins in gastrointestinal infectious diseases.

Dataset Information

Comparative Analysis of Glycoproteomic Software Using a Tailored Glycan Database

Dataset's files

Similar Datasets

OmicsDI is part of the ELIXIR infrastructure

Tweets